I've made the mistake of getting excited about the design of an Android Wear watch before. That time it was the first generation Moto 360. It felt like history repeating itself seeing the Asus ZenWatch 3 up close after its unveiling at the Taiwanese company's IFA press conference.
This is Asus' third Android Wear smartwatch and after two rectangular ones, it's decided to follow Motorola, LG and Huawei by opting for a round watch face this time. It's definitely feels like the right move if you compare it to what Asus came up with for the last two ZenWatches. It's sharp, vibrant and there's no unsightly black tyre at the bottom of the screen (take note Fossil and Motorola). The resolution and screen estate is up there with the best of the Android Wear bunch.
Read this: Face facts, square smartwatches are dying
It's what surrounds it that I feel a little underwhelmed about. Asus talked of jewellery grade stainless steel, diamond cut bezels and rose gold bodies. From afar they look great, but when you actually get your hands on it, they don't feel as luxurious or as polished when compared to something like the Huawei Watch. It's by no means tacky, but it just doesn't feel as nice to interact with. It's a similar story with the straps. There's the option of leather or rubber, which feel perfectly fine on the wrist; they're just not all that different from what we've already seen.
That extends to the physical buttons down the right-hand side of the watch face. Asus claim this is the first Android Wear watch to include three physical buttons, but we know Casio got there first. Pressing them doesn't feel as satisfying as on a traditional watch, but there are at least some interesting ideas when it comes to putting them to use and navigating Google's Android Wear OS. You can also assign your favourite app to the top physical button.
Speaking of apps, it wasn't all that easy to get a proper feel of how Android Wear (not Wear 2.0) felt on the ZenWatch 3. That's because most of the models available for looking at were part dummy units with some of the watch's functionality in tow. It did mean we could check out the pre-loaded (customisable) watch faces that Asus made a big deal about, though.
There's going to be 50 exclusive designer watch faces and six different watch themes, but I can't say I was blown away by the ones I browsed through. Getting those watch faces right is a challenge and I think it's fair to say that traditional watchmakers like Tag Heuer and Fossil have done a much better job of this. There will be a FaceDesigner app letting you make your own watch faces if you don't fancy the ones already included though.
By managing to grab an Asus rep with a fully working model, I did get a taste of how zippy Qualcomm's Snapdragon Wear 2100 processor runs and handles Android Wear, but more interestingly, I also got a glimpse at Asus' new fitness tracking platform, called ZenFit. Much like Motorola's Moto Body software on the Moto 360 Sport, this promises to be a hub for your health and fitness data and works with Google Fit. As you'd expect it can count steps, which Asus claims it has a 95% precision for accuracy.
It also offers automatic sleep tracking, with some pretty basic insights, and it can track certain activities like running and sit-ups. It can also collect heart rate data although of course the ZenWatch 3 does not include a heart rate monitor. The app looks well optimised for the circular watch face and I'm definitely intrigued to see how well it works.
While I didn't get to check them out, it's worth mentioning the accessories Asus is bundling in with the ZenWatch 3. Alongside the watch and the charging dock, you'll also get a watch stand and a portable magnetic charger, which clips onto the back of the watch to add an additional 40% of power.
Asus ZenWatch 3: Early verdict
My expectations were high for the Asus ZenWatch 3 after its big unveiling, but in reality it's another round Android Wear watch that doesn't quite hit that design nail on the head. There are certainly some good ideas, particularly the addition of the physical buttons and some improvements on the battery front. But I fear that like the ZenWatch and ZenWatch 2, it's going to struggle to draw attention away from the better looking round watches from the likes of Huawei, LG and Motorola (even with that black tyre).
The Asus ZenWatch 3 is priced at €229 and is expected to launch before the end of the year.
Shop for recommended smartwatches on Amazon
Wareable may get a commission